Taylor Anderson attorneys Zachary Rutman, Marisa Sanchez and Valeeria Slaiman obtained a significant defense victory on behalf of a County in a lawsuit alleging negligence arising from abuse dating back nearly 60 years.
The San Mateo County Superior Court granted the County’s motion for summary judgment, finding that the plaintiff failed to present admissible evidence establishing that he was in the County’s custody and care at the time of the alleged abuse or identifying a County employee whose conduct could support vicarious liability.
The Court emphasized that speculation, hearsay, and assumptions cannot substitute for admissible evidence, even in cases involving events from decades earlier where historical records are no longer available.
The ruling reinforces important principles governing public entity liability, the evidentiary burdens applicable to historical sexual abuse claims, and the necessity of establishing a legally sufficient connection between the alleged misconduct and the defendant public entity.
This result underscores the importance of rigorous factual investigation, careful evidentiary analysis, and strategic dispositive motion practice in defending complex, high-exposure litigation.